Dave was extremely professional but more importantly I was treated as a person not a case. He always returned calls and emails in a very timely manner. I would definitely recommend Dave to help with legal needs! -Jennifer S.

As someone who never had a lawyer, David made everything as simple as possible. He is very easy to communicate with and provides all the answers and support you will ever need. If I ever need a lawyer again, David will be my first choice to contact. -Andrew

I was falsely accused of something and had an order filed against me. Ben represented me during court and successfully had the order dismissed. He also went above and beyond to make sure it would not show up on my record. – Brittany.

Home » Blog » Attorney Fees after Dismissal

Attorney Fees after Dismissal


Case: Mindy Donovan v. Joshua R. Hastings

Issues: How should attorney fees be calculated after a motion to dismiss is granted?

Facts: Homeowner sued Contractor regarding a contract dispute. Contractor filed a counter-complaint, and then an amended counter-complaint. Homeowner filed a motion to dismiss Contractor’s amender counter-complaint, which was granted. Homeowner then moved for attorney fees, but the trial court awarded only certain attorney fees incurred from her motion to dismiss the amended counter-complaint (but not fees incurred from work before the amended counter-complaint was filed).

Intermediate Decision: In a 2-1 decision, the intermediate court affirmed the partial award of attorney fees, holding that since the amended counter-complaint “superseded and destroyed” the original counter-complaint, no attorney fees could be awarded regarding the original claim. Judge McBrayer, dissenting in part, disagreed: since “the same claim” was in both counter-complaints, attorney fees should be awarded for related work both before and after the amended counter-claim was filed.

Review Granted: April 7, 2021.

Prediction: Ben thinks the Supreme Court will adopt the dissent’s interpretation for the reasons stated therein.